Useful articles
Open Cholecystectomy in Tashkent — When It Is the Right Choice
Laparoscopy has become the standard for gallbladder removal, and many patients regard open surgery as outdated. It is not. Open cholecystectomy remains a necessary and fully justified option whenever working through ports would be unsafe. Every surgeon who performs laparoscopy must also be entirely comfortable with the open approach — that is what makes treatment safe. At Saba Darmon in Tashkent both techniques are used, and the choice is made in the patient's interest.
When the open approach is preferable
- dense scarring and adhesions after several previous abdominal operations;
- neglected acute cholecystitis with a firm inflammatory mass obscuring the anatomy;
- suspected gallbladder cancer, which requires a more extensive operation;
- Mirizzi syndrome and cholecysto-enteric fistulae;
- common bile duct stones that cannot be cleared endoscopically;
- severe cardiac or respiratory failure — insufflating the abdomen raises pressure on the diaphragm and loads the heart;
- coagulation disorders and cirrhosis with portal hypertension;
- bile duct injury identified during surgery and requiring reconstruction.
Conversion is not a complication
Conversion means switching from laparoscopy to an open approach during the operation. It occurs in roughly 2–5 % of elective cases and up to 10–15 % of emergencies.
It is worth being clear: conversion is a marker of good surgical practice, not of failure. It means the surgeon recognised a situation in which continuing through ports had become risky and chose the safer route. The most serious complication of this operation is bile duct injury, and persisting laparoscopically in unclear anatomy substantially raises that risk.
Reasons for conversion include inability to identify structures because of inflammation, bleeding, dense adhesions, discovery of a fistula or tumour, and equipment failure.
How the open operation is performed
Under general anaesthesia a 10–15 cm incision is made below the right costal margin. The surgeon gains direct access to the gallbladder and can assess tissues by touch as well as by sight — a real advantage with a dense inflammatory mass. The cystic duct and artery are then dissected and ligated, the gallbladder removed and a drain placed if required. The operation takes one to two hours.
Where there are stones in the common bile duct, a choledochotomy is performed: the duct is opened, the stones removed and the procedure completed with external drainage or a bypass anastomosis.
Recovery
Recovery is longer than after laparoscopy, and it is worth knowing this in advance:
- hospital stay of 5–8 days instead of 1–2;
- more pronounced wound pain requiring proper analgesia in the first days;
- return to desk work after three to four weeks;
- no heavy lifting for two to three months — important to prevent an incisional hernia;
- a visible 10–15 cm scar.
The diet is the same as after laparoscopic surgery: small frequent meals, limiting fatty and fried food for the first one to two months, then widening the diet gradually.
Comparing the two approaches
Laparoscopy wins on speed of recovery, pain and cosmetic result. Open surgery wins on tactile assessment and on handling difficult anatomy. The long-term outcome — no gallbladder and no more attacks — is identical.
The right question is therefore not "which method is more modern" but "which method is safer in this particular situation".
Preventing an incisional hernia
This is the main risk specific to the open approach. It is reduced by observing lifting restrictions for the first two to three months, wearing an abdominal binder as advised, controlling weight, treating constipation and chronic cough, and stopping smoking.
Consultation in Tashkent
At Saba Darmon the surgeon will review your ultrasound findings, comorbidities and previous operations and explain which approach is planned and why. To book, call +998 71 210-30-30.
Frequently asked questions
Is open surgery worse than laparoscopy?
No. In certain situations it is safer, and the result for the main objective is the same.
Can I insist on laparoscopy?
You are entitled to discuss it with your surgeon, but if they consider the open route safer, their reasoning deserves serious weight.
Is the approach known in advance?
Often yes, from the investigations. But the final decision is sometimes made during the operation.
Will there be a large scar?
Yes, 10–15 cm. It fades over time but does not disappear entirely.
Who performs the surgery
Surgeons and surgical oncologists:
Do you really need surgery? Start with a consultation
Bring your test results to a surgeon: in many cases watchful waiting is enough. Call us to arrange a consultation and pre-operative work-up.
Call now — +998 71 210-30-30Contacts
Address: 7A/3 Nurafshon street, Tashkent
Phone: +998 71 210-30-30 · WhatsApp: +998 95 662-30-30
Opening hours: Monday–Saturday, 09:00–18:00
E-mail:




